Movies Like An Amish Murder (2013)

An Amish Murder is a 2013 drama, mystery, tv movie, thriller film from Stephen Gyllenhaal with a MovieMagicScore of 5.8/10. Here are 20 similar films, ranked by real viewer ratings — starting with Deadly Blessing and Love Finds You In Sugarcreek.

Drama Mystery TV Movie Thriller

Deadly Blessing

1981

When a former member of a religious cult dies in a mysterious accident, Martha, who now lives alone and close to the cult's church, begins to fear for her life and the lives of her visiting friends.

5.5

MagicScore

Love Finds You In Sugarcreek

2014

Will a mysterious stranger's past wreak havoc on a quiet Amish community after they've opened their doors -- and hearts -- to him and his son?

6.4

MagicScore

Witness

1985

While protecting an Amish boy – the sole witness to a brutal murder – and his mother, a detective is forced to seek refuge within their community when his own life comes under threat.

7.1

MagicScore

Amish Grace

2010

When a gunman killed five Amish children and injured five others in a Nickel Mines, Pennsylvania schoolhouse shooting in October of 2006, the world media attention rapidly turned from the tragic events to the extraordinary forgiveness demonstrated by the Amish community.

6.9

MagicScore

Expecting Amish

2014

Expecting Amish tells the story of 18-year-old Hannah Yoder, who is ready to join the Amish Church and marry her boyfriend Samuel. But things change when she goes to Hollywood and gets a glimpse of the world beyond.

6.6

MagicScore

An Uncommon Grace

2017

An army nurse returning from Afghanistan discovers her purpose in a rural Ohio farm community, along with a deep connection with a neighbor whose conservative Amish sect strictly forbids relationships with those outside his church community.

6.5

MagicScore

Love Finds You in Charm

2015

A young Amish woman, who isn't satisfied with her path at home, visits a cousin for the summer. Over the summer, she is exposed to another world, finds friendship and more. Soon she must choose and come to terms with the life she wants.

6.2

MagicScore

The Shunning

2011

Beautiful Katie Lapp has always felt something missing in her simple Amish existence -- until a mysterious "Englisher" comes to Lancaster County looking for the baby girl she gave up for adoption 19 years ago.

6.0

MagicScore

Amish Abduction

2019

Amish wife and mother Annie faces a crisis when her husband leaves the word of the Amish to live among “normal Americans,” or the “English” as the Amish dub them. But things turn even more dire when her husband returns, seeking custody of their son, and is willing to kill to achieve his goal…

5.7

MagicScore

#10

Mute

2018

A mute man with a violent past is forced to take on the teeming underworld of a near-future Berlin as he searches for his missing girlfriend.

5.6

MagicScore

#11

Plus One at an Amish Wedding

2022

April works at a prestigious hospital in New York and has recently met a handsome veterinarian named Jesse. Jesse receives an invitation to his brother's wedding, so he and April travel to Amish Country to meet with those Jesse left behind years ago.

7.6

MagicScore

#12

Follow Your Heart

2020

Kathy Yoder has left her Amish ways and is a successful travel guide writer. When Kathy goes home to settle her dad's affairs, she's reminded of her life before she left the Amish community, including her old love, Isaac. Will Kathy decide to stay or return to her traveling lifestyle?

7.0

MagicScore

#13

Runaway Romance

2018

When she’s written out of her show, her relationship and her seemingly perfect life, reality TV star Ann Stanway leaves Hollywood and finds herself marooned in Amish country. But when Ann is taken in by the owner of a nearby Inn, and meets a handsome young architect, she discovers that the reality she left isn’t nearly as perfect as the one she’s found.

6.8

MagicScore

#14

Violent Saturday

1955

Three men case a small town very carefully, with plans to rob the bank on the upcoming Saturday, which turns violent and deadly.

6.7

MagicScore

#15

The Frisco Kid

1979

Rabbi Avram arrives in Philadelphia from Poland en route to San Francisco where he will be a congregation's new rabbi. An innocent and inexperienced traveller, he is tricked by con men to pay for the trip to go west, then they leave him and his belongings scattered along a deserted road. He is befriended by a stranger, Tommy, who is a bank robber and have many adventures during their journey.

6.1

MagicScore

#16

Saving Sarah Cain

2007

When Sarah Cain, a self-involved big-city newspaper columnist, travels to Pennsylvania for the funeral of her Amish sister, she soon discovers that she is the legal guardian of her five Amish nieces and nephews. Rather than choose to move to Lancaster County to finish raising them there herself, or let them be separated by the foster care system, Sarah decides to take them with her back to Portland where she believes she can make a new life for them. However, she soon realizes that the modern world has forced them to compromise who they are, and that she has moved them there for all the wrong reasons - a motive which is soon exposed - because secrets can really never be kept secret. In order to find her own redemption, she knows she must make a choice to give them back their lives in Amish Country. And whether she remains part of their lives will have a lot to do with how much she has grown to love them.

5.2

MagicScore

#17

Kaw

2007

On the last working day of Sheriff Wayne, his small town is attacked by blood thirsty ravens that eat human flesh. Meanwhile his wife Cynthia visits a farm where a Mennonite family lives to say farewell to her friend Gretchen and discloses a dark secret about the origin of the fierce ravens.

4.5

MagicScore

#18

Devil's Playground

2002

The Devil's Playground is a fascinating and moving documentary about a little-known aspect of Amish life. Amish are not permitted to join the church until their late teens, and have to do so of their own volition. The film explores Rumspringa, wherein young Amish are given the opportunity to explore the "English" way of life.

6.6

MagicScore

#19

How Much Wood Would a Woodchuck Chuck

1976

A documentary short examining the language and performance of auctioneering, filmed at the World Livestock Auctioneer Championship in Pennsylvania.

6.3

MagicScore

#20

For Richer or Poorer

1997

Brad Sexton and his wife, Caroline, are wealthy New Yorkers with both marital and financial problems. The latter issue becomes a pressing matter when they discover that their accountant has embezzled millions and pinned the blame on them. Forced to go on the lam, Brad and Caroline end up in an Amish area of Pennsylvania and decide to pose as members of the religious group to evade the IRS. As the two adapt to the simple Amish lifestyle, they begin to reconnect.

6.0

MagicScore

Frequently asked

What are the best movies like An Amish Murder?

The top films similar to An Amish Murder by MovieMagicScore are Deadly Blessing (5.5), Love Finds You In Sugarcreek (6.4), Witness (7.1). Each shares drama/mystery/tv movie/thriller themes and is ranked by real viewer ratings, not critics or studios.

Is An Amish Murder worth watching?

An Amish Murder holds a MovieMagicScore of 5.8/10 from 73 viewer ratings.

What kind of movie is An Amish Murder?

An Amish Murder (2013) is a drama, mystery, tv movie, thriller film directed by Stephen Gyllenhaal, starring Neve Campbell, Noam Jenkins, C. Thomas Howell.

Where can I find more recommendations like An Amish Murder?

Browse the full ranked list above, or explore more drama recommendations on MovieMagicScore, where every list is ordered by genuine viewer ratings.

Keep exploring

Movies like Deadly Blessing Movies like Love Finds You In Sugarcreek Movies like Witness Movies like Amish Grace Movies like Expecting Amish Movies like An Uncommon Grace

About movies like An Amish Murder

This ranked list pairs An Amish Murder (2013), a drama and mystery and tv movie and thriller film from Stephen Gyllenhaal, with similar titles by genre, theme and cast overlap (fans of Neve Campbell take note). Unlike critic-driven sites, every position here is ordered by MovieMagicScore — a rating built only from real viewers, with no studio marketing or paid placement. Scores update as more people rate, so the list stays current.

← Back to An Amish Murder